Glee - Season 2 Episode 5 - “The Rocky Horror Glee Show”
I stole this screencap from the A.V. Club, because, how could I NOT?
Also, to anyone who follows this up with a comment that looks anything like, “Well if you don’t like it, stop watching!!11,” I. WILL. FIGHT YOU.
It’s a funny thing, going into Ryan Murphy episodes in state of absolute dread. The man gave this show life, but he seemingly has no qualms about destroying it from the inside. It’s his modus operandi, but at least in the cases of Popular and Nip/Tuck, it was all 100% his material to destroy. Glee has the added factor of 1.) being Ian Brennan’s idea in the first place and 2.) having other’s “creations” (and yes, I realize Britney Spears, for example, is really the creation of music writers, marketing teams, and shock value, but you should know what I mean — the brand of Britney Spears and her as a performer) to toy with.
Considering how all three writers share the responsibility of telling the Glee story*, you’d think that they’re also take turns in the big event episodes — especially after how critically-panned “The Power of Madonna” was for its introduction of the ‘music before story’ approach (an approach “Britney/Brittany” took to the next level, even with adding a non-Britney song as a bookend) to Glee. So it’s surprising that Ryan Murphy is still taking charge of these particular episodes.
Then again, if Brad Falchuk were given the Super Bowl episode, for example, he’d probably kill off Burt to the sounds of Rachel confusingly and inappropriately belting “Streets of Philadelphia,” and it would be the most depressing musical tribute episode ever, thus stopping all tribute episodes on Glee and any television show.
…
Actually, on second thought, I’d love for that to happen. Sorry, Burt. Sorry, Springsteen. Sorry, Universe.
This episode will also make Ryan two for two on gimmick episodes this season — we have yet to see what a typical Glee episode from Ryan will be like in season two. Not that there’s anything “typical” about any Ryan Murphy episode (of anything), but you know what I mean.
*I’m sorry, but if you don’t believe in the 3 Glee’s theory, I find you absolutely hopeless, and I suggest you just stop reading this. I don’t even know why you’re reading this. Might I direct you to Fuck Yeah Glee (Ship) Secrets? I’m sure you’ll enjoy it there.**
**Ryan Murphy brings out the bitch in me.***
***The condescending nature is always there though.
On my first viewing, I didn’t completely hate the episode. Yes, I hated Will (he won the Worst Character EVER award for this week, as he tends to do with episodes where Artie’s not the worst — but Artie was an extremely close second, even with just a few lines), but I was somewhat relieved that the Rocky Horror musical within the episode was intentionally bad. I think. That’s what I got out of it. I hope. And I found it refreshing for Finn to have a storyline outside of Kurt, Rachel, and grilled cheese…until I remembered how annoying it is that he is so. damn. insecure. (He has his popularity that he realized wasn’t all that important in the grand scheme of things in the PILOT EPISODE. Why is he so obsessed with the acceptance of his peers? Why hasn’t Ryan Murphy left this show yet?) And I remembered how worried I was by the news of Cory Monteith working his ass off to lose weight and get those lovely abs for this episode awhile back (even though it wasn’t nearly as bad as what Mark Salling went through a the beginning of the first season). And I was happy that most of the characters were written as something other than horrible…but then I realized most of the other characters had absolutely anything to do, so of course they weren’t awful. But then again, I didn’t go into “The Rocky Horror Glee Show” with the same expectations as I had for “Britney/Brittany.”
Prior to the episode, it didn’t so much upset me that this episode and these covers would be many people’s first exposure to The Rocky Horror Picture Show as it did that there are people who will (and from what I’ve read, do) actually find this episode superior to the original stage show and film. At its very best (which isn’t great, I assure you), “The Rocky Horror Glee Show” is a cheap homage (if you squint?) to its predecessors, and at its worst, it’s a bastardization and a spit in the face of anyone who actually cares about the spirit of Rocky Horror. A bit extreme? Yes. Inaccurate? I don’t really think so.
I grew up watching The Rocky Horror Picture Show on VH1 with my mom every Halloween. I have an awful memory as it is, but I’m pretty sure I had absolutely no idea what was going on by the time the movie got to the third act (and to tell the truth, I just watched the movie on Sunday, and I can still pretty much say the same thing). I did eventually figure out that the third act is about a hop, skip, and a jump away from soft-core porn, which sure as hell isn’t going to happen on any network show. But since I’ve come to realize that my story of childhood memories of yearly Rocky Horror viewings (despite the maturity of the film) is a story that a lot of other people can relate to, it’s even more ridiculous that it has to be completely sanitized for a show that is pretty much a caricature of a family show (which, if people actually read the very good GQ article instead of just looked at the shiny pictures and complained about the corruption caused by 24-28 year olds being 24-28 year olds instead of the corruption caused by a perverted man who shouldn’t even still be working in the first place, they’d know that was pretty much Ryan’s intent). The demo they’re trying to censor this all for is the same demo that thinks Miley Cyrus and Taylor Swift are role models.
Don’t you just love it when I bring the social commentary? Pretty soon I’ll be talking about “back in my day” and the crazy noise the whippersnappers today call “music.”
The one thing I can’t completely fault Ryan Murphy on (but don’t worry, he still has quite a bit of fault) is the Frank-n-Furter situation. In case you were unaware, The Stamos was originally supposed to take on that role, but Fox made Murphdalurph scrap that plan and stick with a female, because…trannies are bad and the reason for the decay of the American family? Blah blah blah Rocky Horror is about outcasts blah blah blah but no transsexuals allowed. Yeah, sometimes I forget this show’s on Fox too (if Glee were on FX, we’d have had transsexuals by the third episode, if not sooner), and the move to 8 PM really didn’t help the case. But fear not, gentle readers — there’s still a place to blame Ryan Murphy in this mess. I don’t need to hear Mercedes scream (seriously, that’s what the entire song sounds like to me, and there’s a reason this song is one of the five Glee songs I will ALWAYS skip on iTunes) about being from “sensational Transylvania,” either. I’m not up in arms about having a female Frank-n-Furter, but I am tired of screaming Mercedes (even if I do giggle and say “key change!” every time she starts screaming in “Don’t Stop Believin’ 2.0), and this really is not a song you scream. I will say this every chance I get, but Santana should’ve been Francine-Furter.
Yep, Francine-Furter is what I’m calling this whole mess now.

I can already hear the shouts of hardcore Gleeks (who really are about as shallow as it comes) in protest to my obvious decision to write-off Amber Riley in this role due to her appearance as compared to girls like Lea and Dianna (and this criticism would probably come from those Gleeks who dedicate a considerable amount of time posting about Lea Michele’s legs and Dianna Agron’s…blondeness?). Now, I’m obviously not saying a woman can’t play this role. “If you can dream it, be it,” after all. But even diluted and “family friendly,” the role of Frank-n-Furter/Francine-Furter needs to ooze sex appeal and sensuality. And it’s subtle, which is something Amber Riley’s Glee songs rarely exhibit. This is the only way Francine-Furter can still somehow work. When you hear this song, you should want to have dirty hot sex (sorry, kiddies) with the singer, male/female/undecided/WHATEVER – you don’t even need to know what they look like beforehand. Just hearing the Glee version made me want to swear off sex even more than usual.
Yeah, sorry for the over share, but it needed to be said.
So because I touched upon it earlier, I need to go further into the fact that Will Schuester is not only one of the worst characters the show, but he’s one of the worst characters on television right now. And television has meth dealers as likable protagonists. When Glee began, I truly believe Will cared about the kids in the glee club, despite his misguided ways (disco, rapping, inappropriate student-teacher relations, etc.). In the pilot, when Terri tells him he’s just trying to vicariously relive his glory days, I, like the rest of us, believed that she was just overreacting because she was insane (really, she’s one of the sanest — albeit, woefully misguided — people on this show when you think about it), but there has been so much since then that completely supports her statement.
Let’s take a tally, shall we:
- Gets jealous that The Stamos “made [Emma] better”
- Figures that if he had just taken Emma to Rocky Horror, that would’ve ‘fixed’ her (and hey, if her being ‘fixed’, would lead to him getting laid, I’m sure he’d be ecstatic)
- Lies about his love of Rocky Horror to get on Emma’s good side
- Completely misses the point of Rocky Horror due to his own self-absorption
- Presumably takes the fall musical away from the DRAMA club
- Completely disregards the kids’ initial protests that Rocky Horror is too inappropriate for school
- THINKS ROCKY HORROR IS AN APPROPRIATE SHOW FOR ANY SCHOOL
- Allows Finn and Rachel to be Brad and Janet without auditions or the opinions of the other glee club members, who already have to double up
- “Auditions, schmauditions. This isn’t a gleeocracy — it’s a gleetatorship.” – me
- Makes the kid in the wheelchair be the character in the wheelchair
- Suggests the effeminate gay kid plays the transsexual
- Completely disregards how uncomfortable Sam is in his Rocky costume (and only mentions it in his “reasoning” behind replacing Sam as Rocky)
- Removes Sam from the Rocky role as: a way to have a macho-pissing contest with The Stamos AND a way to get Emma to want him
- Goes after another man’s girl, especially after explicitly promising that he wouldn’t (here’s a wild thought – it’s possible that not everyone likes to cheat on their significant others)
- Gave Kurt’s GREAT Riff-Raff parts in “Time Warp” to Finn (which, okay, Cory actually sounded good, but STILL – when WON’T Will screw Kurt over?)
- Thought the kids’ performances were actually good
- Proven wrong about everything by Sue yet again
- Didn’t keep his shirt off the entire episode
- Didn’t have chocolate for Becky
- Didn’t step down from his position as glee club director and hand it over to The Stamos, who has already shown to care more about the kids than Will does
- Didn’t shut that Mercedes/Francine-Furter mess DOWN
- Lacked the qualities of anything resembling likability
Kicked a puppy <== on the cutting room floor, but I swear it happened
Feel free to add more to this list.
When it really comes down to it, this is not a good tribute episode, and it’s not even a good episode. It’s not necessarily a trainwreck, because it’s really too dull to be. It’s nowhere near as over the top as it should be, which is extremely surprising given the circumstances. For all my loathing of “Britney/Brittany,” that was an episode that went big. And on a personal level, this kind of episode is my greatest fear – I’m currently in the process of writing a spec episode script for Glee, and because of the focus and set-up, I know it’s definitely the type of episode that would be seen in Ryan Murphy’s “big episode extravaganza” Glee. Scary, I know.
And what did any of the characters gain from this episode? Finn and Will were the only ones with anything at stake, and I can assure you Finn will be every bit as obsessed with his status as he was before, and Will will never not be self-absorbed. So why couldn’t we put the focus on characters like Tina, who I would have no problem believing would be into Rocky Horror, or Quinn, who I’m curious to know why she would even know anything about the show given her upbringing, or Kurt, since I would say Chris Colfer was one of the few actually truly into making this episode (especially considering how many of the cast have even said they just don’t “get” Rocky Horror).
Alright, that’s all I need to say about Glee until the next episode in two weeks. Discuss amongst yourselves.
-LaToya (ironicalness)